Buy in November, Sell in December: 10 Items With Built-In Holiday Markup
Every holiday season, the same thing happens. In November, retailers slash prices to pull shoppers in early. By mid-December, the hottest items are out of stock, and late shoppers will pay full price or more to get the gift they promised.
That gap between November sale prices and December demand is one of the most reliable opportunities in reselling. You buy when stores are competing on price and sell when buyers are competing for stock. Here are 10 product types SellerFly's Market Scout is tracking this season that fit that pattern, and how to play each one.
How to pick a holiday flip: four tests
Not every November deal turns into a December profit. Before you buy, make sure the item passes all four tests.

It's discounted now. You need a real price cut in November, not just a "sale" banner on the regular price.
Demand grows into December. Gift items, toys and seasonal fashion get more popular as Christmas gets closer. Everyday items don't.
Supply runs short. Limited runs, retailer exclusives and viral items sell out. Products stocked everywhere stay cheap all season.
It's easy to ship and hard to fake. Small, sturdy items keep shipping costs and breakage down. Brand-name items you can prove are genuine sell faster and for more.
The 10 items
1. Licensed movie and show tie-in toys
KPop Demon Hunters, Bluey, Paw Patrol: The Dino Movie and Toy Story 5 toys are all over this year's hot toy lists. Adobe expects toy discounts to be deepest on Black Friday, and the most popular licensed toys tend to sell out before Christmas. Watch retailer exclusives too, since over half of Target's top 50 toys are exclusive to Target.
Buy: Black Friday at major retailers. Sell on: Amazon, eBay.
2. LEGO and licensed building sets
Popular licensed sets are made in fixed runs, so they can stay out of stock until around February. Adobe names LEGO Pokémon and SMART Play sets among the toys likely to sell best online. Keep boxes sealed and undamaged, and put the set number in your title.
Buy: Black Friday. Sell on: eBay, Amazon.
3. Avengers: Doomsday toys and LEGO sets
The movie opens in US theaters on December 18, and the merchandise is already in stores, including LEGO sets, Marvel Legends figures and a Doctor Doom mask. That timing gives you a second wave of demand right at the end of the gift season.
Buy: November sales. Sell on: eBay, Amazon, into January.
4. Sensory and squishy toys
NeeDoh is on the Toy Insider's Hot 20, and slime and squishy sets appear on both Amazon's and Target's holiday lists. Market Scout rates the margin potential at 4 out of 5, one of the highest in toys.
Buy: Multi-packs on sale. Sell on: Amazon, eBay, TikTok Shop as stocking-stuffer bundles.
5. Nostalgic '90s toys and games
Retro revivals like the 30th anniversary Tickle Me Elmo, Furby and Tamagotchi Paradise are showing up on Amazon, Target and Macy's lists. Adults now account for roughly a quarter of US toy sales, and they'll pay for display-worthy collector editions.
Buy: As early as you can, since hot items sell out. Sell on: eBay, Amazon.
6. Collectible plush
Jellycat, Squishmallows (including KPop Demon Hunters designs) and Pokémon plush all feature on this season's lists, and character plush tends to run short before Christmas. Keep tags on and list the exact character and size.
Buy: Black Friday at authorized retailers. Sell on: eBay, Amazon.
7. Trading card supplies
Every new card set sends collectors looking for sleeves, top-loaders and binders. Pokémon's Delta Reign set lands November 6, with another wave of products on December 4. Bundles (100 sleeves, 25 top-loaders and a binder) sell better than single packs.
Buy: In bulk during November. Sell on: eBay, Amazon, timed to each release.
8. PS5 and Xbox console accessories
GTA VI launches November 19 on PS5 and Xbox, and big game launches lift demand for controllers, charging stations and storage drives. Electronics discounts peak around Cyber Monday, so that's when to buy. PS5 gear is the safer bet.
Buy: Cyber Monday. Sell on: eBay, Amazon in December.
9. Scarves, hats and cold-weather accessories
Fringe scarves, knit skullcaps and knitted hoods are among this fall's accessory trends, and demand runs through January. Accessories avoid the sizing problems that drive clothing returns.
Buy: November fashion sales. Sell on: eBay, Etsy, your own store.
10. Family card and board games
Small card games ship cheaply and make easy gifts. Word-of-mouth family games like SKYJO can run short as recommendations spread through the fall.
Buy: Black Friday. Sell on: Amazon, eBay, listed by age range and player count.
Timing your listings
Buying at the right time is only half the play. When you list and when you cut prices decide whether you capture the December markup.
When | What to do |
Right after you buy | List within 48 hours so your items are live before retail stock thins out |
Early December | Hold firm on price; this is when retail sell-outs start pushing buyers to resellers |
About a week before your platform's shipping cutoff | Advertise "arrives by Christmas" in titles and listings |
Around December 15 | Lower prices on anything still unsold, while there's still time to ship |
After shipping cutoffs | Offer local pickup, or hold evergreen items (LEGO, card supplies, scarves) for January |
Always price against recent sold listings, not other sellers' asking prices. The sold price is what buyers are really paying.
Risks and how to protect your margin
The November-to-December gap is reliable, but it isn't guaranteed. These are the ways it goes wrong, and how to avoid them.
Restocks and reprints. Brands sometimes restock hot items, which can wipe out a markup overnight. Only buy what you can sell even if the price falls back to retail.
Counterfeits. Licensed toys, plush, NeeDoh and blind boxes are heavily faked. Buy from authorized retailers and keep every receipt.
Christmas-only stock. Holiday-themed items lose most of their value on December 26. Favor products that still sell in January.
Overbuying. Set a total budget before Black Friday and stick to it. Unsold stock ties up cash you'll need for the next season.
Shipping and returns. Bulky boxes, glass and batteries cost more to ship and come back damaged more often. Factor that into your buy price.
Track the trends all season
SellerFly's Market Scout is refreshed every week with demand, competition and margin ratings for this season's top products, so you can see which of these 10 are still rising and which are cooling off. Follow @sellerfly on X for weekly updates.
Market Scout is a SellerFly membership feature. Members can log in to see this week's ratings, or view membership plans to join.
Results vary. Nothing in this post guarantees a profit. Always check current sold prices before you buy inventory.
Sources: SellerFly Market Scout trend ratings (updated October 25, 2026), drawing on Adobe's 2026 holiday shopping forecast, Toy Insider, Amazon and Target holiday toy lists, Circana toy sales data, and Pokémon TCG, GTA VI and Avengers: Doomsday release coverage.


